Secretly Recording Your Spouse’s Conversations: What Family Courts Say

May 15 2018

The Legal Drafter

Secretly recording your spouse's conversation can be evidence in family law cases, but it is not always lawful and the court may not accept it. The answer depends on the facts and the state where you record. This guide explains what the family courts have said and how Queensland differs.

Key Takeaways

  • No general right: a court may admit a secret recording, but it may also exclude it.
  • The facts decide: in Janssen & Janssen, the recordings were admitted on the particular facts.
  • State law differs: Queensland, New South Wales and other states have different laws on recording conversations.
  • Get advice first: speak to a lawyer before you record anyone or use a recording.

Why Recordings Matter in Family Violence Cases

Secretly recording your spouse's conversation where there is family violence is an issue that has been discussed widely. When family violence, child abuse and neglect takes place behind closed doors without any witnesses being present, it is very difficult to provide evidence to the family courts when it is illegal to secretly record conversations in some instances.

However, with increasing public awareness and media attention, the difficulties of obtaining evidence behind closed doors is now being recognised by the family courts.

  • The problem: family violence often happens with no witnesses.
  • The risk: recording is illegal in some instances.
  • More reading: see our guide to family violence in family law.

Janssen & Janssen: When Recordings Were Admitted

In the Family Court case of Janssen & Janssen ([2016] FamCA 345), the court noted on the facts before them that, "it is notoriously difficult to obtain evidence of family violence which takes place behind closed doors". The court stated that the decision to admit the secret recordings in this case were based on the particular facts of the case.

The court found that the father had maintained a charming public face but had engaged in conduct that was alleged to have constituted family violence under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth). Three points came out of the case:

  • The facts mattered: the decision to admit the recordings was based on the particular facts.
  • The children: the Independent Children's Lawyer (ICL) submitted that the recordings would assist in determining the parenting abilities of the primary carer, which may have been compromised by the content and tone of the father's communication.
  • Tone counts: it is not only what was said in the recordings, but also how it was said.

What Must Be Proven

The Family Court said that evidence from secretly recording your spouse's conversation in relation to family violence matters will have to meet these tests:

  • Established clearly: the evidence must be established clearly.
  • Opinions in context: matters of opinion are put in appropriate context and given appropriate weight.
  • Who and why: the weight depends upon who was expressing the opinion and on what basis.
  • Background facts: the necessary background facts must be established.

Courts Can Also Exclude Recordings

The court has discretion under section 138 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) to admit or exclude evidence that was obtained improperly or unlawfully. In child-related proceedings, section 69ZT of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) relaxes the rules of evidence. The cases show that the outcome varies.

CaseOutcome
Janssen & Janssen [2016] FamCA 345Recordings admitted
Garner & Garner [2016] FamCA 630Recordings admitted
Coulter & Coulter (No 2) [2019] FCCA 1290South Australian audio excluded
Nagel & Clay [2020] FamCA 326Recordings excluded

An admitted recording in one case does not mean the next court will accept yours.

Queensland Law Is Different From Other States

Please note that the law in Queensland in relation to privacy and the recording of conversations is different from the law in New South Wales and other states.

TopicQueensland (Invasion of Privacy Act 1971)
Using a listening device on a private conversationAn offence under section 43 unless you are a party to the conversation, with a penalty of up to 2 years
Publishing a recording you made as a partyRestricted under section 45
Telephone interceptionGoverned by Commonwealth law
Other statesOften stricter, so check the local law

Because other states are often stricter, a recording that is lawful in Queensland may not be lawful elsewhere.

Potter v The King [2026] HCA 25

On 5 August 2026, the High Court of Australia decided Potter (A Pseudonym) v The King, a South Australian criminal case. The court unanimously held that a covert recording satisfied section 4(2)(a)(ii) of the Surveillance Devices Act 2016 (SA), because it was reasonably necessary to protect lawful interests.

The decision does not create a general right to record. It applies the South Australian statute to its facts. The court's judgment summary sets out the reasons.

Before You Record: Practical Steps

Safety comes first. If you are at risk, call 000, and then speak to a lawyer or a family violence service about the safest way to gather evidence.

  • Check the law: confirm the rules in the state where the conversation takes place.
  • Do not publish: do not share or post a recording without legal advice.
  • Keep it relevant: evidence about the children should link to their care, welfare and development.
  • Get advice: a family lawyer can tell you if a recording is likely to be accepted.

If your matter involves children, see our page on parenting arrangements. If you are thinking of acting for yourself, read about representing yourself in the family court.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it legal to secretly record my spouse in Queensland?

Under the Queensland Invasion of Privacy Act 1971, using a listening device to record a private conversation is an offence unless you are a party to it. A party may record, but publishing the recording is restricted. Get legal advice before you record or use a recording.

Will the family court accept a secret recording?

Not always. A court has discretion to admit or exclude improperly obtained evidence. Recordings were admitted in Janssen & Janssen and Garner & Garner, and excluded in Nagel & Clay and Coulter & Coulter (No 2). The facts of your case will decide the outcome.

Does the 2026 High Court decision let me record my spouse?

No. Potter v The King was a South Australian criminal case about a specific statute. It does not create a general right to record. Whether a recording is lawful, and whether a family court will admit it, still depends on the state law and the facts.

What should I do if I am worried about family violence?

If you are in danger, call 000. Then speak to a lawyer or a family violence service about your options. We can help you with the drafting of consent orders once you are safe and have the advice you need, and you can book a free 15-minute call.

Talk to Us About Your Family Law Documents

We do not give advice on evidence, but we can help you draft the documents once you have decided what is right for your family. Rated 5.0 on Google, Facebook and Trustpilot, The Legal Drafter works with clients Australia wide.

This article contains general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Seek legal advice before recording any conversation.